Strange routing differences for same Waypoint
- Done
|
T |
Tobias Breitwieser |
If I route to the poi of a location (SABA Parkhaus [Energiedienst]) it will partially ignore my charging provider setting on the first war before returning. If I use the adress (Dr.-Pilet-Spur 2, 79868 Feldberg) it uses the right settings for the charging network.
I added the pictures and CSV for the Excel export. And it happened regarding of the preference of Ionity (my only preference) was set to prefer or prefer exclusively.
CSV for strange planning:
-------------------------
ABRP Plan;;;;;;;;;
abetterrouteplanner.com/?plan_uuid=0cdfa216-bd4d-4d4c-b6d8-2ca46fcc6e3c;;;;;;;;;
;;;;;;;;;
Wegpunkt;SoC Ankunft;SoC Abfahrt;Kosten;Ladezeit;Distanz;Fahrtdauer;Ankunft;Abfahrt;Notizen
Robert-Bosch-Straße 28, 64293 Darmstadt;;100%;;;160 km;1 h 31 min;;02:02;
Am Achernsee 1, Achern [allego];41%;84%;11 €;14 min;128 km;1 h 29 min;03:34;03:47;
SABA Parkhaus [Energiedienst];30%;31%;;5 min;83 km;1 h 4 min;05:17;05:22;
Mahlberg Ost [Ionity];12%;77%;38 €;21 min;201 km;1 h 44 min;06:26;06:47;
Robert-Bosch-Straße 28, 64293 Darmstadt;10%;;;;;;08:32;;
6 h 24 min;;;;35 min;573 km;5 h 49 min;;;
-------------------------
CSV for not stange planning:
-------------------------
ABRP Plan;;;;;;;;;
abetterrouteplanner.com/?plan_uuid=13e4262b-f1b9-457e-b3be-ef6487ee4bd5;;;;;;;;;
;;;;;;;;;
Wegpunkt;SoC Ankunft;SoC Abfahrt;Kosten;Ladezeit;Distanz;Fahrtdauer;Ankunft;Abfahrt;Notizen
Robert-Bosch-Straße 28, 64293 Darmstadt;;100%;;;201 km;1 h 50 min;;02:03;
Mahlberg West [Ionity];25%;72%;27 €;15 min;84 km;1 h 1 min;03:54;04:09;
Dr.-Pilet-Spur 2, Feldberg-Ort, 79868 Feldberg (Schwarzwald);35%;35%;;;83 km;1 h 4 min;05:10;05:10;
Mahlberg Ost [Ionity];15%;77%;36 €;20 min;201 km;1 h 44 min;06:15;06:35;
Robert-Bosch-Straße 28, 64293 Darmstadt;10%;;;;;;08:20;;
6 h 16 min;;;;35 min;570 km;5 h 41 min;;;
-------------------------
Activity Newest / Oldest
Tobias Breitwieser
abetterrouteplanner.com/?plan_uuid=4eb085fb-738d-4b24-bcce-e6efe1a19da7
Still wants to go to a random provider for the first part and would easily reach "Mahlberg West" Ionity and will be accepted without an extra stop if you do it manually.
Katya_ABRP
Status changed to: Done
Katya_ABRP
Hi Tobias,
With a preference level for Ionity set to 'prefer' this no longer seems to occur. See plan: abetterrouteplanner.com/?plan_uuid=7ec8cb22-d0ae-4d1b-b99b-e1178f819025
Should you however still see the issue feel free to open a new bug report or simply comment on this one and I'll have it reopened.
/Katya
Samuel_ABRP
Status changed to: Investigate
Samuel_ABRP
Status changed to: User Feedback
Samuel_ABRP
Hi,
i don't really get the problem here. Please explain the expected behaviour. As far as i can see from the plans you sent, Ionity was set to "prefer", which means it uses Ionity preferred but also other networks if it makes sense. In the first plan you stop a few minutes at an A/C charger and the charge level increases by 1-2% which could already change the estimated arrival SoC and result in a different plan.
Tobias Breitwieser
Hi,
What I don't get is why he wants to stop at Alego and not at Mahlberg West (Ionity) as with the other one as it is no problem to reach and would be the preferred charging provider as well as having no detour.
And if you put in the Mahlberg West stop manually, you are even 4 Minutes faster.
So, it is more why he is ignoring the charging preferences here. And if you set ionity to exclusive it makes even less sense. It will send you on a ~30 minute longer tour and ignoring Mahlberg West again.
The 30m detour route:
ABRP Plan;;;;;;;;;
abetterrouteplanner.com/?plan_uuid=29229048-97e4-491c-a179-1d0725c39940;;;;;;;;;
;;;;;;;;;
Wegpunkt;SoC Ankunft;SoC Abfahrt;Kosten;Ladezeit;Distanz;Fahrtdauer;Ankunft;Abfahrt;Notizen
Robert-Bosch-Straße 28, 64293 Darmstadt;;100%;;;86 km;53 min;;16:47;
Bruchsal West [Ionity];71%;82%;7 €;6 min;158 km;1 h 32 min;17:40;17:46;
Neckarburg West [Ionity];21%;65%;25 €;13 min;83 km;57 min;19:19;19:32;
SABA Parkhaus [Energiedienst];30%;32%;;5 min;83 km;1 h 4 min;20:29;20:34;
Mahlberg Ost [Ionity];12%;82%;41 €;24 min;201 km;1 h 44 min;21:38;22:02;
Robert-Bosch-Straße 28, 64293 Darmstadt;10%;;;;;;23:46;;
6 h 54 min;;;;43 min;611 km;6 h 11 min;;;
Samuel_ABRP
This looks indeed a bit odd. I just tried it myself and it seems it tries to Avoid Mahlberg West on the Way to Feldberg, when in Feldberg the AC charger is selected. We will check.
Samuel_ABRP
As a workaround for now please use the location of the Parkhaus without the charger as waypoint, as that seems to give you better results.