1

Don't Route Down Alleys


D
dlu

In Tacoma, WA and Port Angeles, WA ABRP has created routes that use alleys. In Tacoma the route was to the "back door" of a house. In Port Angeles the route was a short cut after a missed turn (and went down the alley the wrong way).

Here's an example: Backdoor" route in Tacoma: https://abetterrouteplanner.com/?plan_uuid=ffaebbe2-2df1-486f-976b-f07001493fa7

Routing through alleys is a problem for a number of reasons:

  • It is or may be perceived as anti-social, especially if it results in a significant increase in traffic in the alley or if folks don't usually drive down the alleys.
  • Alleys are often unnamed, so it makes driving harder because you get a turn with no street name, often just before the street where you expect to turn. If you miss the turn (which is easy when you're expecting a street) ABRP is recalculating right as it should be directing you to turn onto the street you were heading for.
  • It's confusing to the driver when ABRP starts recalculating right about when you were expecting to turn.
  • Over (wired) Apple CarPlay ABRP is lagy enough in a Kia that it adds to the confusion as you're about to make a turn.

Activity Newest / Oldest

Avatar

Katya_ABRP

This ticket has been moved to our new feedback portal;
abrp.featurebase.app/p/dont-route-down-alleys-2


Avatar

Bo_ABRP

Status changed to: User Feedback

Avatar

Katya_ABRP

Merged with: Sent Wrong Way Down An Alley

D

dlu

We were in Port Angles, WA going to the New Day Eatery and overshot on Front Street. To get back to the restaurant ABRP routed us down a oneway alley the wrong way. The link is to a route that I created that reproduces the problem.

To New Day Eatery (the wrong way down an alley: abetterrouteplanner.com/?plan_uuid=3689353d-185a-4c20-a7ae-e34245dfa025


Avatar

Bo_ABRP

Thank you! This seems to be some mapping data which is wrong in OpenStreetMap. Feel free to help the community by editing that street there!


Avatar

Linda

Status changed to: Investigate